Please read full post before responding as it may save you time.
Can anyone give me some suggestions on where to buy 4 new, all-season tires at a decent price?
I am already considering Starfire 2.0s from Coen ($305 with no warranties) or Douglas 88T AS from Walmart ($291 with Road Hazard and 45k mile warranty).
Not interested in Pepboys, Sams Club, or Firestone. Location must be in Washington, PA or very close to it. My car's tires have been to the wear lines for months and I don't feel comfortable driving very far to get new tires.
Tires needed are P185/65R15 for a 2016 Kia Rio LX. I need all four and will need the old four recycled. Refuse to buy retreads. It only takes me 5 minutes to get to work and I stay in-town except for an occasional trip to Pittsburgh.