HELP! Just went to pay our insurance and it is time to renew our policy..our premium went up 300$ a month. Out of no where. Mike and I both have clean driving records, no tickets, dwis, accidents - ever, nothing. We're both over 25. We are with progressive. One car liability an the other full coverage - 573$ a month......I reuse to pay that much. Does anyone have another car insurance company they recommend? I need to get a new policy today....