I know this doesn’t relate to Middletown but I want to recommend a good pizza place that delivered my pizza today within 20 minutes and arrived hot! If you live on the wet side of Middletown then Poppas in Keansburg on Main Street is the place. I know that Valentino’s is good but only if you don’t do delivery. Twice my pizza arrived cold and flopped over after waiting for it to be delivered 75 minutes after placing the order.