Well, I don't like to put businesses down, but in my experience Scott at Jenkinstown is not the sharpest knife in the drawer. Once replaced distributor twice while keeping the same broken cap which was part of the original problem we brought the car in with on an old Honda, and tried to charge me hundreds for his mistakes. I don't have much better to say about his time at Ireland Corners working for Jay necessarily either after he originally closed Jenkenstown; but perhaps he's improved with experience, and become more honorable. However, I'd recommend West Park service ctr. Family business on 9W heading north towards Esopus on left before you get to the black creek preserve, comming from New Paltz. It's probably shorter through Riftin from Rosendale. Number's 384-6666. Very honest and dependable, reasonable prices and won't try to talk you into work you don't need. They also can tow if you need it.