The Old Grist Mill is exceptional...I just figured you've been there before because it's rather well established.
Ann J. replied:
Not Nina's .... not nearly as good as it use to be. Grist Mill is excellent ...
Dan T. replied:
Bottoms up in Slate Hill, NY. It's on rt 284 just off of rt 6. Excellent. http://bottomsuppub.com/resources/Dinner.pdf
Roseanne S. replied:
Dos Amigos has the best guacomole!
Brian F. replied:
http://www.catherinesrestaurant.net/
Robin L. replied:
Catherine's by far...tell Steve (owner) I sent you...been patron and regular for years (he catered my wedding and several dinner parties as well)...also try Tuthill House Grist Mill in Gardiner...fantastic!...I am a major foodie and haven't Not been to restaurant in area...Nina not as good as they used to b, but still nice
Lisa T. replied:
Bottoms Up!
Krisie L. replied:
i agree with Robin, Nina's is not my favorite anymore. Debbie Dos Amigos drinks are great, service is good, and food has been solid in my experiences so far (very afforable).
Brian F. replied:
Some reviews too. Mainly American style fare. Great food, service, and for a restaurant of this quality the portions are phenomenal: http://www.yelp.com/biz/catherines-restaurant-goshen?nb=1
Laureen T. replied:
Coquito in Warwick. .LaVera Cucina in Monroe. .for laid back Ramblers rest in Monroe
Brian F. replied:
Dos Amigos is great! Great Margaritas too!
Doreen C. replied:
Grist Mill is a "special occasion" destination for us. Went there for 25 th and 30 th anniversaries (and in-between, too!) Yes it is a bit pricey but the portions are enormous and the food is sooo good, very traditional. Mountain Brauhaus is old-school German and also delish, has been around for decades.