I'm coming back to NC next week for my parent's 60th anniversary. Does anyone have a recommendation for a good bakery that can make a small sheet cake for the party? ...
Tracie N. replied:
Anthony Dithomas
Paris K. replied:
Harry, im pretty sure. I dont want to give you the wrong answer but you can call tomorow and talk to drew or Melinda 724 202 6518
Roseann H. replied:
Cake Eaters is closed.
Anita P. replied:
Anthony Di Laurie DePinto Thomas
Sylvia C. replied:
Sorry Rick Golba there are no bakery in New Castle anymore. Everyone gets their features at Giant Eagle or Walmart. I moved to Butler because it's so bad!
Dixie H. replied:
Bills Bakery in mahoningtown.
Stacy M. replied:
Cake Eaters on the diamond does a nice job. My family has had 3 cakes & orders cupcakes for events & have always been happy with their baked goods.
Candace B. replied:
https://m.facebook.com/thatsapieceofcakebywendy best cakes ever!!
Nick A. replied:
Bills Bake shop in Motown made our wedding cake and it was very good
Paris K. replied:
Elaine I dont know for sure and dont want to give you the wrong information. You can call tomorow and ask for drew or Melinda Pezzone Moore 724 202 6518
Gina V. replied:
Anthony DiThomas...can make any design or flavor and tastes wonderful!
Yvonne H. replied:
Classic Bakery in Boardman Ohio very good
Scott D. replied:
Anthony Dithomas!!
Dotti W. replied:
Country Corner Bakery makes great cakes!!!!
Elaine G. replied:
Anthony Dithomas
James M. replied:
The Giant Eagle bakery makes good cakes and they're reasonably priced.
Perry B. replied:
Anthony Anthony Dithomas top notch
Nicole E. replied:
Give Melinda Pezzone Moore a call...she owns "Two Fat Guys and an Oven"
Rick G. replied:
Wow! Thanks everyone for all the comments. Joseph Malizia, Leo is my cousin, or my uncle depending on which one you're asking about. Two Fat Guys and an Oven will be getting a call from me tomorrow.
Paris K. replied:
Melinda Pezzone Moore
Jackie T. replied:
Anthony Dithomas
Jim H. replied:
Classic Bakery in Boardman next to Friday's Restaurant. Icing is like New Model's use to be.
Joseph M. replied:
Agree Paris best in nc
Anthony C. replied:
Dani Ritchie <- This girl makes AMAZING cakes. Get in contact with her.