Restaurants in Montauk, NY

Locations ›
NY ›
Montauk, NY ›

Restaurant

All Montauk, NY Restaurants

Nearby Restaurants

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Restaurant, Health & Fitness Instructor...
290 Old Montauk Highway Montauk, NY 11954

9.9

Score Details

Location
Great
Ratings
Great
Recency
Ok

View Profile

(631) 668-2345

Referral from Jul 30, 2013

Steph T.:

Hi! Does anyone have a recommendation on local day spas? It is for a group of girls to go to for a bachelorette outing (so for...

Frantique S.:

Go to Gurney's Inn in Montauk you can go for the day, on top of treatments pay for a day pass and you can use the lockers, the sea water...

See all recommendations 2

Scarpetta Beach

Restaurant
290 Old Montauk Hwy Montauk, NY 11954

9.5

Score Details

Location
Great
Ratings
Great
Recency
Ok

View Profile

(631) 668-1771

Referral from May 01, 2017

Adrian F.:

Visiting Vegas next weekend for my fiancee's Birthday on Cinco de Mayo! Looking for recommendations for any must have brunch or dinner...

Lisa P.:

I LOVED dinner at Scott Conant's Scarpetta! Some of the best food and service I have had anywhere. ...

See all recommendations 1

Duryea Lobsters

Restaurant
65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA Montauk, NY 11954
Closed ⋅ Opens at 7:00AM

9.4

Score Details

Location
Great
Ratings
Good
Recency
Ok

View Profile

Referral from Sep 27, 2013

Phillip A.:

Can someone recommend a lobster roll/place in Montauk for tonight? I'm flying with a friend out there

Caz L.:

Duryea's is great. http://www.duryealobsters.com/

See all recommendations 1

Montauk Yacht Club

Restaurant
32 Star Island Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, USA Montauk, NY 11954

9.3

Score Details

Location
Great
Ratings
Great
Recency
Ok

View Profile

(631) 668-3100

Referral from Apr 03, 2015

Scott S.:

We are looking for ideas for the 40th reunion. 1. Summer or Thanksgiving? 2.Restaurant or Hotel- Do any of you know any Restaurant...

Floyd B.:

www.montaukyachtclub.com

See all recommendations 1

South Edison

Restaurant
17 Edison Dr Montauk, NY 11954
Closed ⋅ Opens at 11:00AM

9.2

Score Details

Location
Great
Ratings
Great
Recency
Ok

View Profile

(631) 668-4200

Referral from Aug 09, 2014

Susan B.:

Going to Montauk tomorrow, will be celebrating 29 years of wedded bliss, anyone recommend a great restaurant for dinner?

John D.:

Happy Anniversary - enjoy! Ate at the South Edison last year and it was great! http://www.southedison.com/

See all recommendations 1

Fishbar

Restaurant
467 E Lake Dr Montauk, NY 11954

7.3

Score Details

Location
Great
Ratings
Good
Recency
Ok

View Profile

(631) 668-6600

Be the first to review this provider

Restaurant referral in Montauk, NY

Referral from April 3, 2015

5.0

Scott S. asked:

We are looking for ideas for the 40th reunion. 1. Summer or Thanksgiving? 2.Restaurant or Hotel- Do any of you know any Restaurant owners on Long Island, perhaps from...

See all responses 25

Restaurant referral in Montauk, NY

Referral from March 18, 2015

5.0

Molly M. asked:

I'd like to suggest our class reunion for this summer include some sort of fundraiser for peter's daughter Sabrina. Suggestions welcome. We can work around the July 4th...